Part 1 · section 1
9. TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF THE MACROSKILLS
Text
💚 9. TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF THE MACROSKILLS
A. FOUNDATIONS OF LANGUAGE TEACHING
- 1. Communicative Competence
- Definition and central concept
- Communicative competence refers to the ability to use language effectively, appropriately, and meaningfully in different social situations.
- It involves knowing not only the grammatical rules of a language but also how, when, where, and why to use particular expressions.
- Successful communication requires linguistic knowledge, social awareness, discourse organization, and communication strategies.
- Language proficiency is demonstrated through meaningful language use rather than memorization of grammatical rules alone.
- Communicative competence is a major foundation of communicative language teaching.
- Dell Hymes and communicative competence
- Dell Hymes introduced the concept of communicative competence in response to the limitations of purely grammatical descriptions of language ability.
- He emphasized that language users must understand what is grammatically possible, socially appropriate, and practically effective.
- Communicative ability involves sensitivity to the cultural and situational contexts in which language occurs.
- Hymes distinguished broader communicative competence from Noam Chomsky's narrower concept of linguistic competence.
- His work influenced sociolinguistics, language teaching, and communicative approaches to language education.
- Chomsky's linguistic competence
- Noam Chomsky distinguished linguistic competence from linguistic performance.
- Linguistic competence: An individual's underlying knowledge of the grammatical system of a language.
- Linguistic performance: The actual use of language in particular situations.
- Performance may be influenced by attention, memory, fatigue, distractions, and other factors.
- Chomsky's concept primarily concerns grammatical knowledge rather than the full social dimensions of communication.
- Canale and Swain's model
- Michael Canale and Merrill Swain proposed an influential model of communicative competence.
- Their original model emphasized grammatical, sociolinguistic, and strategic competence.
- Canale subsequently distinguished discourse competence as an additional component.
- The expanded four-component model is widely discussed in language education.
- Grammatical competence
- Knowledge of vocabulary, word formation, pronunciation, spelling, and grammatical structures.
- Ability to construct and interpret grammatically meaningful expressions.
- Includes sentence structure, word order, tense, agreement, and other language conventions.
- Example: Using the correct verb tense when describing a completed event.
- Grammatical correctness contributes to accuracy but does not guarantee successful communication.
- Sociolinguistic competence
- Ability to use language appropriately according to social and cultural circumstances.
- Includes awareness of politeness, register, formality, relationships, and social expectations.
- Requires sensitivity to age, roles, cultural conventions, and communicative purposes.
- Example: Using a polite request when speaking to a school principal.
- Recognizes that appropriate language varies across communities and situations.
- Discourse competence
- Ability to organize spoken or written language into coherent and cohesive communication.
- Involves connecting sentences and ideas to produce meaningful conversations, presentations, paragraphs, and texts.
- Cohesion: Grammatical and lexical connections between parts of a text.
- Coherence: Logical and meaningful relationships among ideas.
- Includes transitions, reference words, sequencing, paragraph organization, and topic development.
- Example: Delivering a presentation with a clear introduction, supporting explanations, and conclusion.
- Strategic competence
- Ability to use communication strategies to overcome difficulties and maintain interaction.
- Includes clarification requests, paraphrasing, repetition, approximation, and checking understanding.
- Speakers may use gestures or alternative expressions when vocabulary is unavailable.
- Example: Saying "the tool used for cutting paper" when unable to remember the word scissors.
- Strategic competence helps learners communicate despite limitations in linguistic knowledge.
- Bachman's model of communicative language ability
- Lyle Bachman developed another influential framework for understanding language ability.
- The framework distinguishes language competence from strategic competence and other factors affecting performance.
- Organizational competence: Includes grammatical and textual knowledge.
- Pragmatic competence: Includes the ability to express communicative functions and interpret socially appropriate meanings.
- Strategic competence helps language users plan, assess, and carry out communication.
- Bachman's model highlights the complex interaction between language knowledge and language use.
- Pragmatic competence
- Ability to interpret and convey intended meaning within a particular context.
- Includes speech acts, indirect meanings, politeness, conversational implications, and social expectations.
- Speech acts: Actions performed through language, such as requesting, apologizing, refusing, promising, and inviting.
- Pragmalinguistic knowledge: Understanding the linguistic resources used to accomplish communicative purposes.
- Sociopragmatic knowledge: Understanding social expectations governing language use.
- Example: Recognizing that "Could you open the window?" normally functions as a request rather than a question about physical ability.
- Intercultural communicative competence
- Ability to communicate effectively and respectfully across cultural and linguistic differences.
- Includes cultural awareness, openness, perspective-taking, and interpretation of unfamiliar practices.
- Encourages learners to avoid stereotypes and recognize diversity within cultural groups.
- Includes sensitivity to differences in nonverbal communication, conversational expectations, and forms of politeness.
- Learners should develop the ability to clarify misunderstandings without judging unfamiliar language practices.
- Classroom applications
- Role-playing realistic interactions.
- Practicing formal and informal conversations.
- Conducting interviews and group discussions.
- Writing messages for different audiences.
- Interpreting implied meanings and culturally situated expressions.
- Practicing clarification, negotiation, and conversational repair.
- Assessing both linguistic correctness and communicative effectiveness.
- 2. Accuracy, Fluency, and Appropriateness
- Accuracy
- Refers to the correctness of language according to relevant linguistic conventions.
- Includes grammar, vocabulary, pronunciation, spelling, and sentence structure.
- Accuracy is particularly important when errors interfere with meaning or when precision is required.
- Accurate language helps learners convey information clearly and avoid misunderstandings.
- Accuracy-focused activities often emphasize controlled practice and focused feedback.
- Accuracy-focused instructional activities
- Sentence completion exercises.
- Grammar correction and editing.
- Pronunciation drills.
- Vocabulary matching.
- Dictation.
- Structured dialogues.
- Guided sentence construction.
- Transformation exercises.
- Short responses targeting specific grammatical forms.
- Fluency
- Refers to the ability to communicate with relative smoothness, continuity, and ease.
- Fluent communication involves expressing ideas without excessive hesitation or unnecessary interruption.
- Fluency is not equivalent to speaking rapidly.
- A fluent speaker can maintain meaningful communication at a pace suitable for the situation.
- Fluency development requires opportunities for extended and meaningful language use.
- Dimensions of fluency
- Speed fluency: Producing language at a reasonable rate.
- Breakdown fluency: Managing pauses, hesitations, and interruptions.
- Repair fluency: Managing repetitions, corrections, and reformulations.
- Automatic retrieval of familiar expressions supports fluent language production.
- Fluency may be evaluated in both oral and written communication, although its indicators differ.
- Fluency-focused instructional activities
- Free conversations.
- Storytelling.
- Spontaneous speeches.
- Group discussions.
- Debates.
- Interviews.
- Information-gap activities.
- Timed writing.
- Personal narratives.
- Collaborative problem-solving.
- Repeated performance of meaningful speaking tasks.
- Appropriateness
- Refers to the suitability of language for a particular audience, purpose, setting, and cultural context.
- Involves choosing suitable vocabulary, tone, register, and communicative strategies.
- Requires awareness of formal, informal, academic, professional, and interpersonal communication.
- Appropriate language respects social relationships and the expectations of the communication situation.
- An utterance may be grammatically accurate but socially inappropriate.
- Dimensions of appropriateness
- Audience: Adapting language to listeners or readers.
- Purpose: Selecting expressions suitable for informing, persuading, requesting, explaining, or entertaining.
- Context: Considering the setting and circumstances of communication.
- Register: Choosing the appropriate degree of formality and specialized language.
- Tone: Expressing an attitude suited to the communicative purpose.
- Cultural expectations: Recognizing conventions without assuming that one variety is universally superior.
- Balancing accuracy and fluency
- Effective instruction develops both correctness and communicative confidence.
- Excessive correction during spontaneous communication may interrupt learners' flow and willingness to participate.
- Exclusive emphasis on fluency may leave persistent errors insufficiently addressed.
- Accuracy-focused activities are useful when introducing or consolidating language forms.
- Fluency-focused activities are useful when learners need to communicate independently.
- Teachers should vary the degree and timing of corrective feedback according to instructional objectives.
- Corrective feedback strategies
- Explicit correction: Clearly identifying an error and providing the correct form.
- Recast: Reformulating a learner's incorrect statement without directly stating that an error occurred.
- Clarification request: Indicating that a statement requires clarification.
- Metalinguistic feedback: Providing clues about the nature of the error.
- Elicitation: Prompting the learner to produce the correct expression.
- Repetition: Repeating an erroneous expression with emphasis to draw attention to the problem.
- Delayed correction: Addressing selected errors after the communicative activity.
- Peer correction: Allowing learners to provide constructive feedback to classmates.
- Self-correction: Encouraging learners to recognize and repair their own errors.
- Principles of effective correction
- Correct errors according to their significance and instructional relevance.
- Avoid correcting every minor error during communication-oriented activities.
- Give priority to errors that seriously interfere with meaning.
- Provide corrective feedback respectfully and constructively.
- Offer opportunities to apply corrections in subsequent communication.
- Consider learners' proficiency, confidence, and emotional readiness.
- Classroom applications
- Use controlled grammar exercises to strengthen accuracy.
- Use role-playing and discussions to develop fluency.
- Use audience-specific writing tasks to develop appropriateness.
- Combine grammar, meaning, and social context in authentic language tasks.
- Employ assessment rubrics that distinguish accuracy, fluency, and appropriateness.
- 3. Integrated-Skills Instruction
- Definition and principles
- Integrated-skills instruction combines two or more language macroskills within meaningful learning activities.
- The traditional four macroskills are listening, speaking, reading, and writing.
- Viewing is also emphasized as a macro skill in many contemporary language curricula.
- Communication frequently requires learners to use several skills together.
- Integrated instruction reflects the interconnected nature of real-world language use.
- Relationships among macroskills
- Listening and reading are commonly classified as receptive skills.
- Speaking and writing are commonly classified as productive skills.
- Viewing involves interpreting meaning through visual and multimodal texts.
- Receptive activities require active interpretation rather than passive reception.
- Productive communication involves planning, monitoring, and revising meaning.
- Oral, written, and visual communication often interact in authentic tasks.
- Benefits of integrated-skills instruction
- Promotes meaningful and contextualized learning.
- Strengthens connections among different forms of language knowledge.
- Increases opportunities for authentic communication.
- Supports vocabulary development across multiple contexts.
- Encourages critical thinking and information processing.
- Promotes learner engagement and collaboration.
- Helps transfer language skills to academic and everyday communication.
- Allows learners to demonstrate understanding through multiple modes.
- Listening–speaking integration
- Learners listen to information and respond orally.
- Activities include interviews, conversations, oral summaries, discussions, and role-playing.
- Listening provides input for oral communication.
- Speaking provides opportunities to clarify and negotiate meaning.
- Example: Students listen to a recorded interview and discuss the interviewee's opinions.
- Reading–writing integration
- Learners analyze written texts and produce related written responses.
- Reading provides models of vocabulary, structure, organization, and style.
- Writing encourages deeper processing and evaluation of reading materials.
- Activities include summaries, reaction papers, reflective journals, and argumentative essays.
- Example: Students read an editorial and write an evidence-supported response.
- Listening–writing integration
- Learners listen to information and produce written outputs.
- Activities include note-taking, summaries, reports, and response journals.
- Develops selective attention, organization, and synthesis.
- Example: Students listen to a lecture and prepare a written summary.
- Reading–speaking integration
- Learners read materials and communicate their understanding orally.
- Activities include book discussions, presentations, debates, and literature circles.
- Encourages interpretation and evidence-based reasoning.
- Example: Students read a short story and defend their interpretation of the protagonist's actions.
- Viewing integration
- Learners interpret images, videos, advertisements, infographics, and other multimodal materials.
- Viewing activities should examine both visual details and intended meanings.
- Students may respond through discussion, written analysis, presentations, or creative outputs.
- Example: Students analyze an infographic, discuss its claims, and write a critical response.
- Thematic integration
- Organizes learning activities around a common topic or theme.
- Connects vocabulary, language structures, and communicative tasks within one meaningful context.
- Example: A lesson on environmental conservation includes reading an article, watching a documentary, discussing solutions, and writing a persuasive letter.
- Themes can connect language learning to science, history, culture, and everyday experiences.
- Task-based integration
- Organizes multiple language skills around completing a meaningful task.
- Learners use language as a resource for achieving a communicative objective.
- Example: Students research local tourist attractions, interview community members, and prepare a travel brochure.
- Assessment considers both the completed task and the quality of language use.
- Project-based integration
- Learners complete extended investigations or produce authentic outputs.
- Projects require planning, collaboration, research, communication, and reflection.
- Examples include newsletters, podcasts, documentaries, research posters, and community information campaigns.
- Projects provide opportunities to integrate language learning with authentic purposes.
- Instructional sequencing
- Pre-task stage: Activate prior knowledge and establish a meaningful purpose.
- Input stage: Present texts, recordings, or other language resources.
- Processing stage: Guide comprehension, interpretation, and discussion.
- Production stage: Require meaningful spoken, written, or multimodal outputs.
- Feedback stage: Provide responses to both language use and task performance.
- Reflection stage: Encourage learners to evaluate their strategies and progress.
- Assessment of integrated skills
- Performance tasks.
- Authentic communication activities.
- Portfolios.
- Project outputs.
- Oral presentations.
- Written reflections.
- Collaborative tasks.
- Analytical and holistic rubrics.
- Assessment criteria should distinguish the skills targeted by the learning outcomes.
- 4. Communicative Language Teaching (CLT)
- Definition and central philosophy
- Communicative Language Teaching emphasizes learning language through meaningful communication.
- Its primary objective is the development of communicative competence.
- Language is viewed as a means of expressing and negotiating meaning.
- Learners develop proficiency through purposeful language use and opportunities to receive feedback.
- Classroom activities should resemble meaningful situations beyond the classroom.
- Historical development
- CLT emerged prominently during the 1970s.
- It developed partly in response to approaches that emphasized grammatical forms without sufficient attention to communicative use.
- It was influenced by communicative competence, functional approaches to language, and developments in applied linguistics.
- Important contributors to the broader development of communicative approaches include Dell Hymes, D. A. Wilkins, Henry Widdowson, Christopher Candlin, Michael Canale, and Merrill Swain.
- Major principles of CLT
- Meaningful communication is central to learning.
- Learners should use language for authentic communicative purposes.
- Classroom interaction provides opportunities for language development.
- Both fluency and accuracy contribute to communicative competence.
- Errors are understood as part of language development.
- Learners should experience different communicative functions and contexts.
- Language forms should be connected to their meanings and uses.
- Cooperative and interactive learning activities are encouraged.
- Teachers should provide appropriate support without monopolizing communication.
- Characteristics of communicative activities
- A meaningful purpose for communication.
- A reason to exchange information.
- Opportunities for genuine choices in language use.
- Interaction among participants.
- Attention to comprehensibility and successful communication.
- Possibility of more than one acceptable linguistic response.
- Relevance to learners' needs and experiences.
- Information-gap activities
- Learners possess different pieces of information.
- Communication is necessary to complete the activity.
- Students exchange missing information through questions and responses.
- Example: Partners have incomplete schedules and must ask each other questions to complete them.
- Information gaps create genuine reasons for communication.
- Opinion-gap activities
- Learners express differing beliefs, preferences, or judgments.
- Activities encourage justification and negotiation of viewpoints.
- Examples include debates, ranking activities, and discussions of social issues.
- The primary focus is meaningful exchange rather than producing one predetermined answer.
- Reasoning-gap activities
- Learners use information to reach conclusions or solve problems.
- Require interpretation, inference, organization, or decision-making.
- Example: Students compare travel options and decide which best satisfies a family's needs.
- Encourage critical thinking alongside communicative language use.
- Common CLT classroom strategies
- Role-playing.
- Simulations.
- Interviews.
- Information-gap tasks.
- Group discussions.
- Collaborative problem-solving.
- Surveys.
- Debates.
- Problem-solving dialogues.
- Authentic writing tasks.
- Pair and group communication.
- Role of the teacher
- Facilitates meaningful interaction.
- Designs purposeful communicative activities.
- Provides appropriate language models and resources.
- Monitors learners' participation and progress.
- Gives feedback without unnecessarily disrupting communication.
- Creates opportunities for learners to use language independently.
- Supports learners who need additional instruction or guidance.
- Role of the learner
- Participates actively in communication.
- Collaborates with classmates.
- Negotiates and clarifies meanings.
- Experiments with language forms.
- Uses communication strategies when difficulties arise.
- Develops responsibility for improving communication skills.
- Authentic materials
- Materials originally created for real communicative purposes rather than exclusively for language instruction.
- Examples include advertisements, menus, news reports, public announcements, websites, and application forms.
- Authentic materials expose learners to real language use.
- Teachers should select or adapt materials according to proficiency, accessibility, relevance, and objectives.
- Advantages of CLT
- Encourages meaningful language use.
- Develops communicative confidence.
- Promotes learner participation.
- Supports practical application of language.
- Integrates linguistic and sociocultural knowledge.
- Creates opportunities for collaboration.
- Allows varied and context-sensitive communication.
- Limitations and implementation challenges
- Large classes may complicate monitoring and feedback.
- Learners with limited proficiency may require additional scaffolding.
- Some activities may produce limited attention to grammatical accuracy unless carefully planned.
- Unequal participation can occur in group activities.
- Limited materials, time, and teacher preparation can affect implementation.
- Communicative activities should remain aligned with learning outcomes.
- Important clarification
- CLT does not require teachers to abandon grammar instruction.
- Grammar can be taught explicitly when it supports communicative objectives.
- The central principle is connecting language knowledge with meaningful use.
- 5. Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT)
- Definition and central concept
- Task-Based Language Teaching organizes instruction around meaningful communicative tasks.
- Learners use language to achieve an outcome rather than merely practice an isolated language form.
- Tasks create opportunities to understand, produce, and negotiate meaning.
- TBLT is closely associated with communicative language teaching.
- It emphasizes learning through purposeful language use.
- Important contributors
- N. S. Prabhu: Associated with the Bangalore Project and the development of task-based approaches.
- Jane Willis: Developed an influential task-based instructional framework.
- Rod Ellis: Contributed extensively to the theory, research, and pedagogy of task-based language teaching.
- David Nunan: Developed influential approaches to designing communicative tasks and task-based curricula.
- Peter Skehan: Examined task performance, fluency, accuracy, complexity, and cognitive demands.
- Characteristics of a communicative task
- Has a meaningful objective.
- Requires learners to process or express meaning.
- Involves a communication gap, problem, or purpose.
- Allows learners to use available linguistic resources.
- Produces an identifiable outcome.
- Reflects or approximates a real-world use of language.
- Evaluates successful task completion while allowing attention to language quality.
- Task versus traditional exercise
- A traditional language exercise usually emphasizes practicing a predetermined linguistic form.
- A communicative task emphasizes accomplishing a meaningful objective.
- Example of an exercise: Completing sentences using the correct past-tense verbs.
- Example of a task: Interviewing classmates about past experiences and preparing a summary.
- Tasks may still create opportunities for focused attention to grammar.
- Major types of tasks
- Information-gap tasks: Exchanging missing information.
- Opinion-gap tasks: Expressing and comparing viewpoints.
- Reasoning-gap tasks: Solving problems or drawing conclusions.
- Decision-making tasks: Evaluating alternatives and reaching an agreement.
- Problem-solving tasks: Using information to address a meaningful problem.
- Jigsaw tasks: Combining information distributed among learners.
- Narrative tasks: Reconstructing or telling events.
- Planning tasks: Preparing schedules, events, or proposals.
- Creative tasks: Producing meaningful original work through language.
- Pre-task phase
- Introduce the topic and communicative objective.
- Activate relevant background knowledge.
- Provide necessary vocabulary and conceptual support.
- Clarify instructions and expected outputs.
- Present models or examples when appropriate.
- Organize learners for individual, pair, or group participation.
- Reduce unnecessary difficulty without eliminating meaningful learner decision-making.
- Task-cycle phase
- Learners perform the communicative task.